The age-old debate of whether Goku from Dragon Ball could defeat Saitama, the protagonist of One Punch Man, has divided anime fans for years. While some claim Saitama’s limitless power would obliterate Goku in an instant, others argue that Goku’s unparalleled feats and transformations in the Dragon Ball universe place him far beyond Saitama’s reach. In this post, we’ll delve into the evidence to assess their strengths, weigh their abilities, and reach a reasoned conclusion.
1. Saitama’s Strength: Two Versions
To accurately evaluate Saitama’s capabilities, it’s important to note that there are two canonical versions of him: the original webcomic by ONE and the re-drawn manga by Yusuke Murata.
Original Saitama: In the original webcomic, Saitama’s feats are impressive, particularly his battle against Boros. Boros’ final attack, the Roaring Cannon, was stated to have planet-level destructive capabilities, and Saitama’s Serious Punch easily countered it. This places him at a confirmed planetary level.
Awakened Saitama (Manga): The re-drawn manga takes Saitama’s power a step further, particularly during his fight with Awakened Garou. In this battle, Saitama performed moves like the Serious Sneeze, which blew away Jupiter’s gaseous surface—an achievement approximating dwarf-star-level power. By extrapolating the power of his Serious Punch, it’s estimated to be around 500 times stronger than his sneeze, placing him at a star-level in terms of striking power.
2. Goku’s Power Scaling
Goku’s power scaling throughout the Dragon Ball series is legendary. Starting from his early days in Dragon Ball Z as a Super Saiyan capable of destroying planets to his later exploits in Dragon Ball Super, Goku has consistently broken barriers and surpassed expectations.
Super Saiyan God and Beyond: The introduction of transformations such as Super Saiyan God and Super Saiyan Blue marked exponential growth in Goku’s power. His battles against powerful beings like Beerus, the God of Destruction, demonstrated Goku’s ability to clash with and withstand universe-shaking attacks. By the time Goku mastered Ultra Instinct, he was capable of fighting on par with deities, exhibiting unmatched speed, reflexes, and combat precision.
Ultra Instinct Mastery: One of Goku’s most defining power-ups is his mastery of Ultra Instinct. This technique allows him to move and fight without conscious thought, elevating his combat prowess to divine levels. His battle against Jiren, one of the most powerful mortals in the multiverse, and his confrontation with Moro, a magic-wielding planet-eater, are testaments to his god-tier strength.
3. Comparing Strengths
Destructive Power:
Saitama: Awakened Saitama’s peak performance includes feats like his Serious Sneeze, which affected Jupiter at a dwarf star level. While highly impressive, this is consistent with a character whose power is capable of obliterating large planetary bodies. This level of destruction showcases that Saitama’s punches pack immense force.
Goku: Goku’s Ultra Instinct grants him the ability to face and overpower opponents with universal-level destructive potential. His fights against Jiren and Moro demonstrate his capability to endure and counter threats that can impact entire universes. The fact that Goku has defeated opponents capable of obliterating universes places him in a different tier of destructive capability.
Speed and Combat Ability:
Saitama: His speed is depicted as near-instantaneous, but the exact limits of his speed are not explicitly defined within the context of One Punch Man. His fight choreography suggests he moves faster than the eye can follow, but without specific measurements, it’s difficult to place him definitively.
Goku: Ultra Instinct allows Goku to react without conscious thought, a skill that surpasses even the reflexes of gods. His combat speed has been demonstrated to exceed the speed of light, making him one of the fastest characters in anime. Battles where Goku fights at FTL (faster-than-light) speeds further underscore this advantage.
Endurance and Stamina:
Saitama: One of Saitama’s defining traits is that he never tires. Despite fighting the strongest foes, he shows no sign of fatigue. This seemingly limitless stamina is a major advantage, suggesting that if a battle were prolonged, Saitama would have the upper hand.
Goku: While Goku has remarkable endurance and is known for his relentless training and battle spirit, he does have limits. However, he compensates for this with the Saiyan trait of growing stronger after each fight, allowing him to evolve mid-battle.
4. Debunking Common Misconceptions
Saitama as a Gag Character:
While many fans see Saitama as a gag character who wins for comedic effect, the creator ONE has clarified that One Punch Man exists in a serious universe where Saitama’s unmatched strength contrasts with the struggles of those around him. This nuance means that while he is overwhelmingly powerful, he is not invincible by definition. His power has a thematic basis, emphasizing the absurdity of unmatched strength in a world where everyone else strives.
The “One Punch” Myth:
It’s crucial to understand that Saitama’s “one punch” victories are not an unbreakable rule but a theme explored within his own world. In crossover scenarios involving fighters like Goku, the assumption that Saitama could end any fight with one punch might not hold. The context of a battle in which Goku could adapt, power up, and use strategic combat would test whether Saitama’s usual modus operandi would suffice.
5. Goku’s Adaptive Fighting and Strategy
One significant advantage Goku holds over most opponents is his fighting intellect. Over years of battle experience, Goku has learned to read opponents and devise effective strategies. His Saiyan nature allows him to push past his limits and adapt in real time, turning the tide of battle.
Ultra Instinct in Action: When Goku uses Ultra Instinct, he becomes a near-untouchable force, capable of dodging and countering attacks without conscious thought. This reflexive state would allow him to potentially withstand Saitama’s initial barrage and find a way to turn the fight in his favor. Combined with his martial arts expertise, Goku’s strategic prowess could tip the scales.
6. Final Showdown: The Hypothetical Battle
If these two titans were to meet in battle, it would be nothing short of cataclysmic. Goku’s ability to sense and amplify his energy, teleport vast distances using Instant Transmission, and adapt mid-fight would come into play. On the other side, Saitama’s sheer strength and unwavering determination would make him a formidable challenger.
The Power Scaling Limit: While Saitama’s strongest known feat so far is at the star level, Goku’s battles have reached universe-destroying stakes. This crucial difference suggests that Goku could match or surpass Saitama’s power in a drawn-out fight. Saitama’s lack of a clearly defined upper limit means he could potentially evolve further, but until that is explicitly shown, Goku’s universal feats remain unmatched.
7. Verdict: Who Wins?
Based on current power scaling and available information, the evidence leans in favor of Goku. Ultra Instinct Goku has repeatedly overcome opponents with universal-level power, a threshold that Saitama has not yet demonstrably surpassed in his highest feats. While Saitama’s potential is vast and could evolve in future developments, the data as of now points to Goku as the victor.
Final Thoughts
The debate between Goku and Saitama will continue to fuel discussions among anime fans. Saitama’s comedic dominance over his world makes him a unique and formidable figure, but Goku’s consistent track record of defeating god-level and universal-level threats positions him as the likely winner in this legendary matchup. Until Saitama’s true limits are explored further, Goku stands as the stronger warrior—at least for now.
Would you like more content like this? Share your thoughts, and let’s keep the discussion going!